storyâGrey is far more prolix in his clues, as in the passage above, which paraphrases, in one of several such moments, the novelâs last line; rather, it is the suspense of wondering what the larger stakes of the plot are. The knowledge of what is at stake is imbued in Greyâs landscape: it may be just wind on stone, but something like God seems to be there. It is not a God Grey identifies, but we know itâs not meant to be the Mormon one. It is older than America, and Greyâs protagonists sense its presence as if it will become a final revelation.
In the same year that Mormonism officially gave up polygamy so that Utah could join the Union, the U.S. Census declared that the frontier line of settlement no longer could be said to exist: the consolidation of the American West was nearly complete. The larger significance of the battle for Jane Withersteenâs freedom is suggested when Lassiter tries to make her see what is at stake in her fate. Jane insists, âIâm an absolutely free woman,â to which Lassiter somewhat triumphantly replies, repeating national arguments about Mormon womenâs âslavery,â âYou ainât absolutely anythinâ of the kind.â In a passage that seems to blur distinctions between Lassiterâs and Mormonismâs omniscience and even between Mormon and American imperial designs, Lassiter explains:
Jane, youâre watched. Thereâs no single move of yours, except when youâre hid in your house, that ainât seen by sharp eyes. . . . When you rode, which wasnât often lately, the sage was full of sneakinâ men. At night they crawl under your windows, into the court, anâ I reckon into the house. . . . This here groveâs a humminâ bee-hive of mysterious happeninâs. . . . This all means, Jane, that youâre a marked woman. . . . Jane, youâre to lose the cattle thatâs leftâyour home anâ ranchâanâ Amber Spring. . . . I told you once before about that strange power Iâve got to feel things.
While Lassiterâs âstrange powerâ imitates the Mormonsâ own, he intuits what the Mormons cannot: how the plot will make him a hero. Jane responds, âWhat does it mean? . . . I am my fatherâs daughterâa Mormon, yet I canât see! Iâve not failed in religionâin duty. . . . When my father died I was rich. . . . What am I, what are my possessions to set in motion such intensity of secret oppression?â Lassiter responds succinctly, âJane, the mind behind it all is an empire builder.â He adds, âThey tried you out, anâ failed of persuasion, anâ finally of threats. You meet now the cold steel of a will as far from Christlike as the universe is wide. Youâre to be broken. Your bodyâs to be held, given to some man, made, if possible, to bring children into the world. But your soul? . . . What do they care for your soul?â The âmindâ that is âan empire builderâ is here left unspecified. This lack of specificity curiously opens up Lassiterâs pronouncements to a meaning quite opposite his own, for if Jane is read to represent Mormonism and its possessions, the mind that is an empire builder with a will of cold steel could stand for the federal government and its policies toward the Mormons in the latter half of the nineteenth century, before the Mormon church was âbrokenâ into giving up polygamy, the âsoulâ of the Mormon religion.
The sense of paranoia that Lassiter seeks to instill in Jane was one with which Mormons were familiar during the period of government investigations beginning in the 1880s and continuing episodically to Greyâs time. In the sequel to
Riders,
Grey includes an awareness of the investigations. Minister Shefford asks Presbrey why he says the Mormons close to the Utah line are âunfriendly these days,â and Presbrey responds,