hefted the bag of nails. âAnd this isnât a full pound of nails. Less than half, Iâd say.â She turned the small burlap bag over and looked at the faint red lettering. âThese didnât come from my store. I think thereâs been a mistake.â
âBut I heard someone yell there was a thief.â
âI did, too. Maybe itâs just someoneâs idea of a joke.â
âItâs not a joke.â A man stepped out of the crowd.
Emma locked eyes with the irritating man who had twice kept her from catching the lad. In the sunlight, she could see that, beneath the battered brim of a felt hat, his hair was a reddish brown, a shade lighter than his eyes. The air was chill, but sweat darkened his collar and lathered his shirt and suspenders to his chest, which had been so hard against her. His shirttail hung out of his trousers, drawing her gaze to the well-worn denims that followed his muscular legs. His boots might once have had a shine, but now were dull with dust. This was a man who was toughened by strenuous work and proud of it.
As she looked back to his face, she swallowed her gasp when he gave her an unexpectedly roguish smile. It seemed to suggest he knew far more about her than any living man should. With a slow, sensual perusal, his gaze slipped along her, appraising her as she foolishly had him. Heat swelled each place his eyes touched.
He put his fingers to the brim of his hat. âMaâam.â
âWho are you?â Lewis asked. âThis your boy?â
âHardly.â The manâs lips became straight again.
Emma said quietly, âSheriff, why donât you ask the boy his name?â
âWhatâs your name, boy?â
The youngsterâs shoe traced a pattern in the dust as he mumbled, âSean OâDell.â
âOâDell? There arenât any OâDells around here,â the sheriff retorted. He gave the boy a shake. âTell the truth, lad.â
Reverend Faulkner stepped forward and put his hand on the sheriffâs arm. âHeâs telling the truth, Sheriff. I recognize him. Heâs one of the youngâuns who just arrived on the train.â
Lewisâs voice grew hard. âOn the orphan train from back east? Is that true, lad?â
âYes, sir,â the boy murmured, an Irish brogue lilting through his words.
âYouâre not making a good new start, lad.â He turned to the man who was still frowning. âAnd who are you, mister? Are you with these kids?â
âI am Noah Sawyer, and I want you to punish this boy for theft.â
His brows arched. âStrong charge, Mr. Sawyer.â
âOnly the truth. That boy stole the hammer and nails from my wagon over there.â He pointed to a dilapidated buckboard in front of the store.
The sheriff looked at the boy. âIs that true?â
âI didnât really steal them.â He shuffled his toe again in the dusty road. âI was just looking âround. I wanted to see what this place was like. We went through lots of towns on the train, and I wanted to see one up close. So I was looking âround. Then he came up and I got scared and I ran and he chased me andââ
âI think Iâve got a good idea of what happened.â Lewis smiled when he turned back to Mr. Sawyer. That smile wavered when Mr. Sawyer continued to scowl. âSounds like it was just a boyâs curiosity, sir.â
âSounds like he was poking his fingers into things that donât belong to him,â Mr. Sawyer fired back. âThereâs a big difference between looking and helping yourself.â
âTrue, and Iâm sure the boy knows the difference.â He gave Sean another small shake. âTell the man you do, son.â
âDo know that, sir,â he said, not looking up.
âNow that youâve been caught?â Mr. Sawyer asked.
Emma suspected she would regret getting more involved in this,