very first time.
Those were very different butterflies.
âI think we should break up,â I say softly. The words hover in the air between us like theyâre in a cartoon speech bubble. Cole barely reacts at all, but I notice the corner of his mouth twitch. For several seconds the only sound is the crashing of the waves against the hull of the ship. I wait, as patiently as I can, for the explosion of feelings thatâs probably welling up inside him right now.
âWhatever,â Cole says finally.
Not exactly what I was expecting.
âWhatever?â I snap back.
âWhat do you want me to say, Elvs?â
âSomething more than âwhatever.â We have a child together, for Christâs sake.â
â Youâre the one who just said you want to break up!â
Iâm at a loss. I want so badly for Cole to understand. I want to tell him that heâll always be my first true love, that heâll always be the father of my child, and that there will always be a special place in my heart just for him. That Iâll always want him in my life, but that Iâm growing into a different person from who I was when we met, and that I need to figure out who this new person is going to be. I want to tell him Iâm sorry.
âFine. Whatever, then,â I shoot back at him.
My mouth feels like Iâve been chewing on cotton balls. I crack open the silver can and take a huge sip, only to immediately spit it back out in a glorious spray over the bow of the ship.
âJesus, Cole! What in the hell is this?â I run my finger along the lip of the can, picking up the thick white liquid. âHave you been drinking condensed milk ?â
âIt was all they had in the galley!â he shouts. âAnd, hey, I donât have to explain myself to you, because we just broke up !â
With that, he storms away, brushing past Captain Oates, who is walking toward us. Cole doesnât break his stride and starts running as he gets farther away from me. Oates looks back at him before turning to me with a concerned look on his face.
âMiss Elvie?â he asks. âYouâre crying.â
âItâs nothing,â I say, holding up the can of syrupy milk. âJust went down the wrong pipe.â
âAh.â Oates settles in right beside me and looks out at the water. I can tell he doesnât believe me, but heâs way too British to let on. âItâs quite lovely, isnât it?â
âYeah,â I say, sniffing.
âItâs been too long since Iâve been on the water. I hadnât realized how much I truly missed it.â
âWell, seems like you could have called your buddies here to escape from prison anytime you wanted to.â
âI broke the law of my people, even if I felt that law to be unjust. If I wanted my actions to mean something, I could not run away from their consequences.â
âI didnât realize extra hanky-panky was such a weighty subject for you,â I say. Seriously, Iâve always thought the Almiri âcodeâ was a bit bogusâdeciding who a dude gets to sleep with, and then locking him up indefinitely if said dude canât keep it in his pantsâbut my buddy Oates has taken things to a new level of bogusitude.
Oates looks me dead in the eye. Now Iâve done it. I should just keep my mouth shut for the rest of the trip so that I donât piss anyone else off.
âThese sailors who aid us in our journey home . . . ,â Oates begins.
âThe smugglers? What about them?â
âThey are not smugglers. Well, they are, but not in the manner that you suppose. They are freedom runners. They transport the, shall we say, recently liberated, to safer harbor.â
âYou mean like escaped convicts?â I ask.
Oates shrugs. âPerhaps, sometimes. But not always. They have been making their covert runs for centuries now.â
âTheyâre