deaf. Good for everyone. She spent a month or so trying to figure out ways she could make this happen, with thoughts of sharp pencils and other pointed objects, but she couldnât come up with anything that wouldnât cause pain and get her into trouble.
Finally she mentioned it to George.
âNo, God, no. You canât be thinking those kinds of thoughts,â he yelled.
They were at the river, so he could shout. Not loudly â George was never loud â quietly, as though that same stuffed animal was having a small amount of success with making itself heard.
He could see that he had alarmed her with the ferocity of his reaction.
It was late spring, nearly three years after the knife incident. George was twelve; his sister was eight, in grade two. She had failed grade one, couldnât get the hang of things. Mostly she gazed out the window or stared at her classmates and teacher. She didnât manage much better the second time around but it was decided that she should move ahead anyway. They couldnât keep her in grade one forever.
âI hate myself, Georgie,â Morven said now on the bank of the river.
âNo, you donât.â
âYes, I do.â
âItâs not good to say that even if you think it,â said George.
âWhy not?â
âItâs a sin.â
âWhatâs a sin?â
âSomething thatâs wrong.â
âWho says whatâs wrong?â
âGod, mostly.â
âIt doesnât count then. Godâs dumb.â
âDonât say that, Mor.â
âWhat can I say? All the things I want to say you tell me not to. What am I supposed to say? What am I supposed to think? Everything I think is wrong too.â
George stood up and retrieved his glove and baseball from where he had left them in the sparse shade of a young oak tree.
âLetâs play some more catch.â
âCan I tell you something?â said Morven. âPlease?â
âIs it about hating yourself or deafening our mother or something equally as horrible?â
âNo.â
âOkay, then. I guess so.â
George sat down again on the long grass beneath the tree.
âCome into the shade,â he said. âYour face is getting baked.â
Morven plunked herself down and put her hands to her sunburned cheeks.
âA girl at school invited me to play,â she said.
âYeah?â
âI told her no. I said, âIâve already played.ââ
âThat was a stupid thing to say.â
âI thought so.â
George took his baseball out of the glove by his side and examined it.
âWhatâs her name?â
âGloria.â
âLetâs go and call on her and ask her to come out and play with us now.â
âNo.â
âWhy not?â
âI donât know where she lives.â
âShe lives up on Coniston in one of the poor people houses.â
âI donât want to.â
âMaybe if we called on her and asked her to play with us you wouldnât hate yourself so much.â
âNo, I hate myself more than that. Calling on Gloria wonât help.â
âIt might.â
âNo. It wonât.â
She stood up and walked toward the edge of the riverbank. She walked so close that George hurried to join her.
âHer face turned sad when I said it,â said Morven. âIt looked like it might start to cry.â
He wanted to tell her that Gloriaâs face was a she and not an it. But he bit his tongue to keep from speaking.
They sat with their legs hanging over the abrupt edge where a chunk of earth had broken away from the bank.
âI hate my face,â she said. âI hate my whole head, really, except for my eyes.â
âWell, at least you donât hate your eyes,â George said. âThatâs good, I guess.â
âYeah. I hate my glasses but I donât hate my eyes. Without them, I wouldnât be