receiverâs fault when theyâre not caught.â
âBut it is.â
Brian looked like he wanted to hit me for being so dense. âDoes it make any difference how a pass is thrown if the receivers you throw it to canât catch it? He might as well miss you by ten feet if theyâre gonna come barreling in at ninety miles an hour. Danny doesnât really want to win, he just wants to be thought of as a great person whoâs being held back by mediocrity.â
This was too much for me: I didnât understand how a human being could not want to win and yet appear to. I guess it would be fair to say that Brian had just provided my introduction to an intellectual recognition of the unconscious. âYou mean, heâs intentionally losing?â
Brian smiled. Just a slow movement of the mouth, a private look of gentle contempt. âNo, I donât mean that.â
He meant to allow the subject to be dropped, but I knew that if I permitted him to, I should be admitting stupidity. âPlease explain,â I said. âIâm sure youâre right and I want to understand.â
âYouâre sure Iâm right and yet you donât understand what Iâm saying? Thatâs silly.â
âNo, itâs not,â I said in a hurt tone. âYour description of Dannyâs play is accurate, so your explanation of it must be right. What difference does it make if I understand it? I donât understand the A-bomb, but it exists.â
Brian opened his eyes wide in astonishment and then laughed. His laugh was a series of staccato grunts, theatrical and self-loving, but flattering because they seemed to be a kind of appreciative gesture. âBoy,â he said, letting out a few more, âthat makes touch football pretty important.â
âIf you can explain the A-bomb instead, then go ahead.â
He laughed again, and I knew we were friends. It was the kind of joke only friends enjoy. âWell,â Brian said, âwhat I meant was that Danny is considered the best passer among us because he throws that way. So people think of him as a winner even though his team loses.â He looked at me. âGot that?â
âYeah! I got that.â
âOkay, just checking. Soâhe could try to win the games if he passed so that his receivers could catch the ball. But heâd have to throw less perfectly. And if he then missedâI mean throwing ordinary passesâthen he would still lose the game and he would also lose everybodyâs respect.â Brian stopped and looked inquisitive.
âUnderstood.â
âOkay. Heâs scared to try and win because losing is so safe. See? He wins the good opinion of others by losing the game because of his teammatesâ faults, and he never has to risk his own skill.â
âWow,â I said. I felt the exhilaration of true knowledge: I understood suddenly how an alien being functioned. âWow, thatâs amazing.â
Brian smiled his private smile. âIsnât it?â He was pleased by my excitement. âIâve always known that about Danny but nobody else has spotted it.â
I thought for a moment and then said, âSo Danny is intentionally losing, as I said.â
âNo!â Brian slammed his hand down on my bed and I heard the jangle of the creaking springs. âNo, no, thatâs wrong. He does this without realizing it. He thinks heâs doing his best. He says to himselfâhimself! he says it to me all the timeââIf I had decent receivers Iâd beat you.â See? Deep down heâs scared to put himself on the line. Thatâs why I say he doesnât really want to win. All he really wants is for people to think he can.â
I absorbed this, my first perception of subconscious desires in other people, in silence. Awed silence. Brian paused for a comment and that encouraged me to ask, âBut isnât that just as good as