into it until they softened into an orange-colored mass.
Now Birch, her mouth nicely puckered from juicy dill tomato, asked the question sheâd been trying to avoid. âWhy did they boo that man? I thought he was okay in the movie.â
The old manâs answering smile was as tart as the dill tomato. âHe was a Friendly.â
âYeah,â Patrick said, his lips white with powdered sugar from his blintz. âHe ratted on people he thought were Communists.â
âOnly most of them werenât,â Scotty added. âAnd even the ones who wereâI mean, being a Communist wasnât illegal when they joined the party back in the thirties.â
Birch spent the next five minutes being lectured to about the House Un-American Activities Committee, the Hollywood Ten, the blacklist, the graylist, Red Channels, a man named Dalton Trumbo, another man named Walter Winchell, and a lot of other ancient history that meant absolutely nothing to her.
Mendy sipped his black coffee, grimaced, and reached into his pocket for a tiny pillbox. With yellowed smokerâs fingers, he lifted the lid, took out a small white tablet, andslipped it into his coffee. He stirred, drank again, and smiled at Birch, who was watching the operation closely.
âMy grandfather had nitroglycerin pills for his heart,â she said in a low voice. âBut his doctor wouldnât let him drink coffee.â
âThese arenât nitro, kid,â the old man replied. âJust saccharin. Iâm a diabetic, gotta watch my sugar.â
âGinger Rogers, too,â Patrick said. âWasnât she a Friendly?â
âNo,â Mendy said, his sharp eyes narrowing with bad memories, âthat was her ma.â He shook his head. âPoisonous woman. Had a tongue on her so sharp itâs a wonder she still had lips.â
âI always liked that Gene Kelly tried to fight the blacklist,â Scotty said. âHim and Bogie and Bacall.â
âDonât forget the divine John Garfield,â added Patrick. âThey all went to Washington to protest the Committee. But then the studios cracked down and they all folded.â
âThe whole thing scared the hell out of Kelly,â Mendy agreed. âThe First Amendment committee, Bogie, Bacall, Eddie Robinson. They make their big statement and then come back to Hollywood and find out theyâll be fired unless they tell the world they were duped by the evil Commies. It killed Garfield, the whole mess. Friends on one side, friends on the other, people going to jailâit ate him up inside, and one day he just died.â
Patrick asked the question on everyoneâs mind: âDid you get called before the Committee, Mendy?â
âBelieve it or not, I did. Went to a couple meetings, next thing I know Iâm Public Enemy Number One. They hauled me up there, wanted me to name names. I said, hell no, I wasnât gonna rat out my friends. Never worked again in the Industry. Not one dayâs shooting did I get after that.â
âWow,â Birch said, impressed. âBut why didnât you just tell them you were a Communist for a while but you didnâtwant to name anybody else?â For some reason, she didnât mind showing her ignorance before the old man. It was okay to know less than a guy who must be eighty years old.
âWhat you have to understand,â Mendy said, âis that you couldnât do that. Once you answered one question, you had to answer them all. Thatâs why the Ten took the Fifth.â
Birch nodded as if this made sense. She supposed she knew what taking the Fifth meant, but who were the Ten?
âThe Hollywood Ten,â Patrick whispered into her ear. âA bunch of writers. They refused to answer and they went to jail.â
âSo if Iâd gone in there and said, hell, yeah, I was a Commie and proud of it, or if Iâd even said, I was a Commie and Iâm