shook with disgust and disappointment. It was from my biological father, Chuck.
A crazed man with blue eyes and dark, curly hair stood in front of a comically oversized cake under a Happy Birthday banner, holding a gun to his head. Guests surrounded a table, all in exaggerated death poses, tongues hanging out, eyes rolled back. Chuck had written a banal message on the inside of the card, closing the note out with âWell, hereâs the birthday card I modeled for. Love you.â
Granted, it was better than the other birthday card heâd sent a few years later, the one with a woman dressed in a trench coat and lacy lingerieâthe printed text reading, âPlay with it again, Sam.â
I pushed both cards face down into the folder, questioning whether to throw them out. Truth be told, I was questioning everything.
My husband had always accused me of having âabandonment issuesâ because of Chuckâor as I called him, the Mother Chucker. Suffice it to say, Iâd always harbored a deep resentment for my biological father. Anybody of sane mind would. After a year and a half of marriage, he left my mother and me for another woman. Stole the car. Drove off into the California sunset. Left the door to our apartment open so the cats escaped. Didnât even leave a note. I was six months old, jaundiced and colicky. My mother was twenty-one years young, fearful of her future. Even worse, the Mother Chuckerâs family wrote us off too, cutting off all correspondence.
Still, life went on for my mother and meâand it was a much better life. When I was six, she married the man I proudly call my dad, Tony. As a precocious five-year-old, I probably played a tiny role in his decision to marry us when I looked up at him with wide blue eyes and asked, âWill you be my daddy?â And no, my mother did not prompt this question. It was all meâa little girl who wanted to complete the family circle.
Tony accepted my proposal and Mom married him one year later. I wore my hair in Shirley Temple ringlets to their wedding. Our life was great, no, fantastic, all rainbows and marshmallows and unicorn-perfect, or at least, it was to me. Chuck wasnât around to veto the judgeâs ruling, and my dad formally adopted me when I was ten.
Two months after my adoption had gone through, my mother gave birth to my baby sister, Jessica. Thanks to Peter Mayleâs book Where Did I Come From? , I knew enough about the facts of life when I stated matter-of-factly, âDad is going to love her more than he loves me. Sheâs his real baby. And Iâm not.â
Then I burst into tears.
Mom and Dad sat me down and explained that just because my dad didnât make me during one of his happy sneezes (as depicted in the book) it didnât mean I wasnât his real daughter. Love didnât come from just DNA. I was still jealous of the attention my sister received but, for the time being, the issue had been resolved. I forgot about my adoption, my old last name. I was a Platt and proud of it.
Until the day I was reminded I wasnât born a Platt at all.
Which brings me back to Chuck.
Deadbeat daddy-o first made contact when I was twelve years oldâright when I was in the throes of puberty, right at the time I didnât fit in. As if life wasnât confusing enough. Naturally, his wish to get to know me upset my mother, but she gave me the choice to speak with him or not. Curious about my origins, Iâd hoped to get some answers. Like, why? Why did he leave my beautiful mother? Leave me? Yet I was too nervous to ask these questions.
Soon after this first phone call, the gifts arrivedâa red suede coat from Saks and a pair of diamond earrings. Like that could make up for never paying child support. In eighth grade, I lost one of the earrings. A jealous classmate destroyed the jacket; the blue pen marks scribbled on the back of it couldnât be removed.
After he made this
The Governess Wears Scarlet