underhanded threat she had been prepared to make to Dr. Bertrand. It was a threat she had rehearsed but couldnât quite remember if sheâd delivered. It was a sly implication of how she knew exactly what heâd done for her brother; and how he could go to prison for it. Other doctors certainly had, while Dr. Bertrand remained a free man, untarnished and unapologetic.
She could remember perfectly the feeling in the city that day. Music, the mayhem of mass celebration, the streets of Montreal roiling in dance, bells, singing, the clatter of pots and pans, horns, comet-like streamers tailing through the air above the streetcar wires and landing amid a brass-band frenzy.
For Claire, dancing with Dr. Bertrand the day of the false armistice was only the end of this memory song. The beginning, like most controversial things, featured her grandmother.
Claireâs paternal grandmother was an eccentric. She had been widowed early, and had raised Claireâs father by scraping by on what little money her husband had left behind. She read voraciously, blasphemed at will, and every year she lived sheâd become less and less of a believer, first renouncing the sacraments. By the time sheâd come to live with her son, his straitlaced wife, and their three children, Claire, Cécile, and Daniel, she had stopped going to church altogether.
Instead, on the Sabbath, with no one else home, she would shuffle over to the neighboursâ apartment â immigrants from France, and non-believers as well â where she would sip cognac on their terrace, discussing books, news, and politics. It was unheard of, scandalous even. But what tipped her scale into the realm of eccentricity was how unashamed she was. â Je mâen fous ,â she would say, whenever Claireâs father or mother challenged her to consider what other people might say about the things she did or didnât do. âIf you do come across someone who has issue with me,â her grandmother would calmly say, âtell them that I am always right here. They are more than welcome to discuss their qualms, with me, to my face.â At which point she would retire to her boudoir, and close the door conclusively behind her.
Her grandmotherâs boudoir was a tiny room filled with sofas, as well as a rocking chair and an anniversary clock that didnât keep time so well. Several small paintings â rollingly idyllic Quebec landscapes â adorned the walls, interrupted by a window that looked out onto the dreary brick partition of the next apartment. It was a room designated for the women in the house to sit in quietly with their needlework, but it was really only used by Claireâs grandmother for reading, and for âpoisoning her granddaughters,â as Claireâs mother liked to say, âwith her audacious ideas.â
Claire and Cécile adored their grandmother. Once the door to the boudoir was closed, she was easily distracted from her reading and took a genuine interest in the girls and their fantastical whims and play worlds. She would gently clap and hum a tune and Claire would dance and spin on the rectangle of a second-hand rug in the centre of the room, which acted as a padded stage. She would endlessly reread the same fairy tales and stories to Cécile, who learned the words by heart and would mouth them as they were being read, her legs draped over her grandmotherâs lap, enveloped by her large arms, as a wrinkled hand was lifted to lick a finger for turning the page.
When Claireâs grandmother first moved into their apartment, in 1910, Claire was seven, Cécile ten, and Daniel fourteen. That same year, a man named Henri Bourassa started up the newspaper Le Devoir , which had a liberal, anti-imperialist, intellectual tilt, and of which Claireâs grandmother became an instant disciple. Its daily reading was the only thing she did religiously. But the next two years saw her sight, already