research, and he is presently a member of the National Football League Player Engagement Advisory Board.
In a sense, Koonce is the consummate âparticipant observerââa researcher who has been embedded in his research subject most of hislife. Heâs an authentic insider who has seen and done it all. Koonceâs observations and insights inform the analysis throughout the book. In addition, the other authors (Jim Holstein and Rick Jones, both sociologists at Marquette) spent dozens of hours interviewing Koonce, conducting in-depth life history interviews. These interview data also appear throughout the book, with Koonceâs stock of experiential knowledge of football, the NFL, and retirement supplying the empirical bedrock for this study. In addition, the book draws upon dozens of formal, in-depth life history interviews as well as many more informal interviews conducted with former NFL playersâplayers with experience on a variety of teams, from different eras, playing different positions, from diverse social, economic, and racial backgrounds, and experiencing varying degrees of success and financial reward in the NFL. Several other academic studies of NFL players, former players, and their families also provide revealing first-hand data. Finally, the book draws on narratives and interviews on retirement-related issues from a wide variety of media sources, citing hundreds of players. 12
The sports and entertainment media provide plenty of sensationalized, sweeping generalizations and judgmental conclusions about life after football. An anecdote here and there is usually deemed sufficient to warrant the claims. But an empirically narrow, predetermined focus often distorts playersâ lived realities. Itâs likely to ignore complexity and discount the mundane. Life after football is as complex and variegated as it is in any other segment of society. Itâs just lived in a spotlight, or under a microscope, but thereâs more to discover if we recognize and honor the complexity, nuance, and paradoxes of ex-playersâ lives that defy easy characterization. 13
Recently, head injuries have been the big story. Prior to that, money dominated the discussion, with reports of monumental TV deals and collective bargaining agreements juxtaposed with lurid tales of profligate spending and bankruptcy. Crime, domestic violence, social relationships, sexuality, isolation, and addiction claimed the sidebars. But none of these issues emerges in a vacuum. Nor do they develop in stereotypic lockstepwith media images. Like everyone else in 21st-century America, former NFL players live at the complicated intersection of race, social class, gender, and the economy. Everyone faces the mundane challenges of getting by from day to day in a world of jobs, bills, ailments, and relationships. Life after football is no different. If the challenges are distinctive, itâs due in large part to the radical social changes that players encounter when they exit the game. When NFL players leave football, they encounter a version of culture shock. They arenât just retiring from a job or a career. Theyâre leaving a way of life, entering a world that is foreign to them. They know the languageâsort ofâbut they speak a distinctive dialect. Theyâve seen the sights from afar, but theyâre no longer tourists or disinterested onlookers. Now they live in the neighborhood. The world after football for some players is so different from what theyâve experienced for their entire adult lives that it leaves them disoriented.
NFL players are tough, talented, and well-compensated. Their lives revolve around competition and commitment. Violence and injury lurk around every corner. Teamwork, loyalty, and camaraderie are transcendent themes, juxtaposed with individual glory and respect. Beyond question, the NFL is a
manâs
world, where masculine pride and character are constantly challenged. Even