cousin?â
His hands moved up to squeeze her shoulders. âI didnât screw her, Mi.â
âSure.â
He traced his fingers down her arms, kneading at the muscles bunched with tension. Warm tingles followed every inch of skin he touched. âShe came to me after the party that night. I didnât even know she was in the room until I woke up. I thought it was you.â
âIs that supposed to help?â Panic gripped her. She shouldnât be responding. Shouldnât fucking care what he had to say. It would be so much easier to walk away in that moment than to relive the memories. Color her a glutton⦠âI mean, really? You thought she was me? She might be my relative, but there must have been some distinguishing differences you could have noticed.â
âI did.â He nodded, his gaze intent. âMaybe too late to stop all of this from happening, but I did. She was already naked, touching meâand when I realized it wasnât you, I was furious.â
âEnough to finish what sheâd started and then promise not to tell me?â She couldnât help wanting to hurt him. Sheâd been heartbroken, angryârelieved? No. That couldnât be right.
His grip on her arms tightened, the line of his jaw tensing. â Nothing was finished that night. I kicked her out once I realized what she was up to. I promised not to tell you what she â d tried to do. Her reputation was bad enough, but adding that stupid move would have killed her mother. Hell, her dad had threatened to send her away, and things were so bad in your family already, I thought it would be betterââ
âWhat?â she interrupted. âBetter to lie to me?â
God, she wished he didnât sound so sincere. Wished he wasnât saying all the things sheâd thought he might say, over the years, when her pride had been too bruised to let her come crawling back home. She wished more that his touch didnât affect her as much as it did. Sheâd spent a lot of time trying to hate this man, and he was breaking down her reasons without much effort. Evidently, New York hadnât hardened her the way sheâd hoped. âIf thatâs all true, why didnât you just tell me?â
âMiya,â he breathed. The warmth of his hand soaked into her skin as he cupped her cheek. âYou always stuck up for her, always rooted for her and believed in her when no one else would. I knew it would destroy you to find out sheâd tried to do this to you. I made a bad decision when I chose not to tell you what sheâd done. At the time, I thought it was the best way to handle it all.â
âSo you did it for me?â Nausea rolled through her stomach. He had no idea what his stupid decision had cost them, and the old anger sparked deep in her heart. âYou didnât think Iâd be hurt more believing youâd fooled around with her?â
âThe way you say it makes it sound stupid.â His eyes narrowed. âI did it for us. For your family. I thought I could keep it a secret.â
Miya stared at him. Did it matter now? Four years was a lifetime when your life ended and began again in one night. Sheâd picked up the pieces alone. There was no way she would let his reasoning scatter them around again. âIt doesnât make any difference now anyway.â
âIt does to me.â
âYour feelings stopped being my concern four years ago.â Damn, this was hard. If the feelings sheâd buried long ago would stay where they belonged, it would be much easier to walk away. âIâve moved on, Shawn.â
âSo did I, at least for everyone else to see.â He let out a slow, measured breath. âBut I couldnât. I canât. Not knowing that the moment I saw you again, everything I ever wanted had walked back into my life.â
Tears welled in her eyes. How many nights had she wished to hear him say
Mary Ann Winkowski, Maureen Foley