should have happened?â
âThere was a case for exclusion then,â Brian said. âIâm not disputing that. But what about later? What about now? We have more food, more energy, more everything than we need. The cities could support ten times as many people as they do.â
âSo we could live in mobs again, like in the twentieth century?â That was another boy, Roland. âLetâsbring the savages in and live alongside them in Âtenement buildingsâis that what you want?â
âNo, of course I donât.â Brian suddenly seemed to realize the absurdity into which his argument had led him, and looked uncertain. âAnyway, I was talking about servants, really. Theyâve lived in the cities for generations. We call them servants, but if we were honest we would call them slaves. Theyâre born in slavery, live in slavery, die in slavery. In ancient Rome slaves had a slim chance of getting their freedom. Our servants have no hope at all.â
There was a general murmur of disgust. The reference to ancient Rome had something to do with it. No one was interested in the Dark Ages, either early or late. And it wasnât true about slavery. Servants were paid money for their workânot a lot, it was true, but too much, many said, for the amount they did. âSlaveâ was an unpleasant expression which had no place in the civilized world of the twenty-third century.
Martin said, âYouâre just talking rubbish, Brian. The servants donât mind being servants, any more than the savages mind being savages. Theyâre used to itâcontented, in fact.â
Brian asked, âHow do you know?â
Roland said, âI know something. I know Iâve had enough of this talk. I mind that. Letâs have some more music.â
âYou wonât think,â Brian said. âNone of you will. Thatâs the troubleâyou wonât let yourselves think.â
âIâll tell you what I think,â Martin said. âI think you should shut up, Brian, or else do the thing properly and go out and join Wild Jack.â
That raised a laugh. We could all remember being told stories about Wild Jack by our nurses when we were little: Wild Jack, the bogeyman who would creep up from the Outlands, steal over the wall by night, and take back naughty children to his lair among the savages. Martinâs remark reduced the subject to the level of the ridiculous, which was its proper place. Brian made a feeble attempt to continue with his protests, but no one was listening any longer.
After all, what point was there in talking about the Dark Ages or the savages, far away either in time or space? Servants brought out more food and drink. The sky was black above, but the lamps shone gaily in the trees. It was still warm, but if the evening wereto turn cold, thermostats would switch on the heaters. A long boat, lit up from stem to stern, drifted past on the river, and farther off I heard the high whine of a speedboat.
The Outlands, we knew, were wild and trackless, inhabited by hungry, murdering savages, but all that was on the far side of the wall. We were snug in the city. I saw a high light in the distance, marking the summit of the energy tower.
Someone had turned up the music, and couples joined together to dance. Brian had seemingly accepted defeat and now had other things in mind. He came over and asked Miranda for a dance.
She gave him a small, cool smile. âIâm sorry. Cliveâs already asked me.â
I hadnât, in fact, but I didnât argue about that. I took her out onto the circle of polished wood, laid down by the servants between the trees. For the first time I felt there had been some point in the grinding tedium of dancing lessons. She danced lightly, humming in tune to the music. It was good to hold her and see her face close to mine in the lamplight.
2
M Y PARENTS VISIPHONED FROM RHODES the day before the