brought with him to the movie; he suggested that a woman customer turn to a waiter, when Sallyâs orgasm was over, and say: âIâll have what sheâs having.â The line, by the way, was delivered in the movie by Estelle Reiner, Robâs mother. So there you have itâa perfect example of how The Process works on the occasions when it works.
I donât want to sound Pollyannaish about any of this. Rob and I disagreed. We disagreed all the time. Rob believes that men and women canât be friends (HARRY: âMen and women canât be friends, because the sex part always gets inthe wayâ). I disagree (SALLY: âThatâs not true. I have plenty of men friends and thereâs no sex involvedâ). And both of us are right. Which brings me to what
When Harry Met Sally
is really aboutânot, as I said, whether men and women can be friends, but about how different men and women are. The truth is that men donât want to be friends with women. Men know they donât understand women, and they donât much care. They want women as lovers, as wives, as mothers, but theyâre not really interested in them as friends. They have friends. Men are their friends. And they talk to their male friends about sports, and I have no idea what else.
Women, on the other hand, are dying to be friends with men. Women know they donât understand men, and it bothers them: they think that if only they could be friends with them, they would understand them and, whatâs more (and this is their gravest mistake), it would help. Women think if they could just understand men, they could
do something
. Women are always trying to
do something
. There are entire industries based on this premise, the most obvious one being the womenâs magazinesâthere are hundreds of them, there are probably five of them in darkest Zaire aloneâthat are based completely on the notion that women can
do something
where men are concerned: cook a perfect steak, or wear a perfect skirt, or dab a little perfume behind the knee. âRub your thighs together when you walk,â someone once wrote in
Cosmopolitan
magazine. âThe squish-squish sound of nylon has a frenzying effect.â
When a movie like
When Harry Met Sally
opens, people come to ask you questions about it. And for a few brief weeks, you become an expert. You seem quite wise. You give the impression that you knew what you were doing all along. You become an expert on friends, on the possibilities of love, on the differences between men and women. But the truth is that when you work on a movie, you donât sitaround thinking, Weâre making a movie about the difference between men and women. Or whatever. You just do it. You say, this scene works for me, but this one doesnât. You say, this is good, but this could be funnier. You say, itâs a little slow here, what could we do to speed it up? You say, this scene is long, and this scene isnât story, and we need a better button on this one.
And then they go off and shoot the movie and cut the movie and sometimes you get a movie that youâre happy with. Itâs my experience that this happens very rarely. Once in a blue moon.
Blue Moon
was another title we considered for a minute or two. I mention it now so you will understand that even when you have a movie youâre happy with, thereâs always somethingâin this case, the titleâthat you wish you could fix. But never mind.
Â
FADE IN:
DOCUMENTARY FOOTAGE
of an OLDER COUPLE, a MAN and a WOMAN. Theyâre sitting together on a love seat looking straight at the CAMERA
.
MAN Â Â Â Â I was sitting with my friend Arthur Kornblum, in a restaurant, it was a Horn and Hardart Cafeteria, and this beautiful girl walked inâ
(he points to the woman beside him)
âand I turned to Arthur and I said, âArthur, you see that girl? Iâm going to marry her.â And two weeks later we