that.â
âYes, please do,â said the inspector. âAnd how about a couple of chairs? Thereâs no need for us to be uncomfortable.â
He motioned to the constable inside the room, and a space was cleared where the conversation could proceed with some semblance of privacy. Temperley found himself back in the arm-chair by the fire, while the inspector shoved another opposite him, and sat down in it.
âHow would you like me to do it, inspector?â inquired Temperley, who had been thinking hard during the interim. âIn my own words, or will you help me with questions? This is the first murder Iâve ever been present at, so you must excuse me if Iâm a bit green.â
âI can see youâre green,â responded the inspector, not unsympathetically, âor youâd be more careful of the words you use.â
âWhat have I said?â
âYou said you were present at the murder.â
âOh, I see.â Temperley paused. âWell, Iâll amend that, if I may. I donât know whether I was present or not.â A sudden thought came to him. âNoâI couldnât have been!â he exclaimed, impulsively. âThat shotâI never heard it.â He paused again. The inspector was watching him closely. âUnlessââ
âYes, Mr. Temperley. Unless?â
âUnless I was dozing,â concluded Temperley, rather lamely.
âAnd the shot woke you up?â
âYes.â
âThe noise was not recorded, however, in your waking dream.â
âHow do you know?â
âYouâd have mentioned it, obviously.â
âSo I would. NoâI heard nothingâeither waking or dreaming.â
âDo you deduce anything from that?â
âWhat do you mean?â
As Temperley asked the question and found the inspectorâs eyes boring into him with a sort of grave persistence, he began to realise the personality he was dealing with for the first time. This was no ordinary official. The inspector was a human being struggling through a queer and difficult world side by side with other human beings, and conscientiously carrying out his particular job. Relentless in his duty, perhaps, but sympathetic behind the relentlessness. So, at least, Temperley judged him at this moment; and, in the strange battle that was to ensue between them, he had many subsequent opportunities of testing this judgment.
Whether the judgment were right or wrong, the immediate result of it was to lighten a little the load on Temperleyâs mind, and to render him more natural. But he did not like the theory towards which the inspector seemed to be workingâthe theory that the murder had been committed before Temperley had entered the smoking-roomâ¦and before the lady had left itâ¦
âWhat I mean is this,â the inspectorâs voice broke in on his thoughts. âSome guns bite without barking.â
âA silencer!â exclaimed Temperley, quickly.
The inspector noted his relief.
âYes, this shot was probably one of the silent kind. But before I advance my theories, let me know your facts, Mr. Temperley. You said you were staying here only a few hours?â
âYes, Iâve just come off the night-train from Preston.â
âFive a.m.?â
âThatâs right.â
âGlasgow train, isnât it?â
âI think so, but I only joined it at Preston.â
âAndâbefore that?â
âWindermere.â
âOn a holiday, eh?â
âYes.â
âI see. Well, and when your train arrived at Eustonââ
âWait a minute, inspector. We must go back to Preston.â
âOh?â
âThe dead man and I shared a first-class compartment from Preston.â
Fresh interest shot into the inspectorâs eyes at this information. âYou know him, then?â he demanded.
âMerely as a snoring travelling companion,â answered