some implausible stories from her best friend, Folly Flood, Rye couldnât help but ask, âMama, what about Beyond the Shale? Shouldnât we worry about monsters?â
To which Abby OâChanter had replied, âRiley, have you ever seen a monster come out of the forest?â
âWell, no.â
âThere you go,â Abby had said. Then sheâd added with a wink, âBesides, if one did, wouldnât you rather be the first to see it coming?â
âI suppose youâre right,â Rye had said. And that had been the end of those worries.
Still, that night at supper, Rye wasnât feeling particularly thrilled about where they lived, or anything else for that matter. She sat with her mother and her little sister, Lottie, at the big table by the fireplace, picking at the fleshy white meat in the cracked shells on her plate. Her place setting was remarkably tidy. Typically, when Rye was hungry, the table and floor looked like a pantry raided by squirrels.
âSea bugs again?â Rye said. âI wish we could have something else.â
Sea bugs washed ashore in piles each morning. They were brown and gray until you threw them into a boiling pot, then they screamed, turned red, and fought with each other to escape. Rye felt no gratitude toward the deranged person who first strolled along the sand and ate one.
âCackle fruit!â exclaimed Lottie, banging her spoon on the table. Rye wondered if Lottie would outgrow the bangingâand the yelling and fussingâwhen she turned three. That was coming soon, but not soon enough.
âEggs are for morning,â Abby said. âBesides, somethingâs been troubling the hens. They havenât laid any eggs all week.â
âUh-oh,â said Lottie, bending her head over the big claw on her plate. As she pecked at it, her nest of red hair bounced, and coarse strands flew out in all directions like a barn fire. Her hair was nothing like Ryeâs, which was brown and chopped short above her shoulders, or their motherâs, which fell long, thick, and black down her back.
âAs for you,â Abby said, pointing a spoon at Rye, âbe thankful we have sea bugs and bread. You know we canât afford to eat beef or chicken every night.â
âWell, we could . . . ,â Rye mumbled.
âAnd what do you mean by that?â
Rye bit her lip. âNothing.â
Abby always seemed to know when something was weighing on Ryeâs mind. Rather than cuff her, or warn her not to talk back, Abby usually tried to help. It wasnât easy being Rye. Abby seemed to know that.
âWhat is it, Riley? Youâve been upset all day.â
âItâs just . . . the Constable. He lied to us today. You knew he was making up laws and you didnât say anything.â
Her mother nodded.
âWhy not?â Rye said. âYou let him treat us like weâre stupid.â
âMe no stupid, me Lottie,â Lottie said. She made an angry face and pounded her fist on the table.
âOf course, Lottie,â Abby said, and patted her red tuft.
Abby looked back at Rye. âThe Laws of Longchance, Riley. You know that weâwomen, girlsâweâre not supposed to know those things. Weâre not supposed to know how to read or write.â
Unless you are a Daughter of Longchance, Rye thought, in which case none of those laws applied. Her mother had told her that there were other places where girls and women could do anything they wanted. Abby grew up in one of those places. When Rye asked why they couldnât move there, Abby told her it was complicated. When sheâd asked again, Abby said there were worse things than not being allowed to read or write. The third time sheâd asked, Abby sent her down to catch the basement wirry under the Willowâs Wares.
âThose are stupid laws,â Rye grumbled now, her ears turning pink.
âThey are stupid,