represent Fifth Amendment Communists. Either we serve a client or we donât, and you canât serve a Fifth Amendment Communist. The second alternative would be to lie, and then you take your chances with a five-year perjury rapâagain with other lawyers. We donât advise our clients to commit perjury.â
Suddenly, his voice changed; it became soft and warm and ingratiating. âNow isnât that a hell of a note, for me to talk to you like that, Harvey. The thing for us to do is to get down to cases and work our way out of thisâand come out clean and proper. Iâm your attorney, you understand? Weâre in a crisis now, and we have no secrets from each other. Suppose we get down to cases. Were you ever a member of the Communist Party?â
âCan he understand?â Crane asked himself. âCan anyone understand? Thereâs no use getting sore at Jack Henderson. I should be proud and pleased that I have someone like Jack Henderson to stand by me. But how can he understand? Did he ever reel a knot of hunger in his belly? Did he ever know what it means to go for a week with never more than ten cents in your pocket? Did he ever stand on a soup line?â Such thoughts filled him with self-pity, which restored some of the pleasant state of ennoblement he had felt after talking to Jane. Once again, he felt a part of a certain elect, a man of unique sensitivity and experience, apart from other men.
He sensed that he was being seared now by deep and angry flames, and out of the chaotic flow of his thoughts, there emerged vague currents of creativity, a sense of wonderful things he would write in the future, the drama of hurt and inner suffering, not the, bald, vulgar pain of people who were poor, hungry and cold, but the deeper travail of those who struggled with their own souls and emerged in a victory composed of meekness and humility. And so he said to the lawyer, his voice low and compassionate,
âJack, Iâm not here only as a client, but also as a friend. If I seem headstrong, itâs due to a lack of knowledge. Then itâs up to you to put me straight.â
âIâm glad to hear you say that, Harvey. Iâm damn glad to hear you say that. Now suppose we talk.â
Crane talked. He told how he had joined the Communist Party in 1934, of his poverty, his heartsickness and despairâof how suddenly he found friends, comrades, warmth, of how he became a part of a little group of actors and writers who were working for and dreaming of a new kind of theatreââ
âIn other words they used you as a dupe for their ends,â Henderson said understandingly. âHow long did you remain a member?â
âUntil September of 1935. That was when my first play was produced on Broadwayâthe first bit of success I ever had. It brought me to my senses, I suppose.â
âAll rightânow the thing is this, Harvey. When you were a member of the party, you met with a group. We have to have a list of the people in that group, and when the time comes, you have to be prepared to name them.â
âName them?â
âThatâs right, Harvey.â
Craneâs face fell. âThe truth is, Jackâand youâve got to believe meâthe truth is I donât remember but one of them. There were only seven or eight in that group, and it is almost twenty yearsâand I canât for the life of me recall their namesâââ
Hendersonâs face hardened. âYou said you were leveling with me, Harvey. Do you mean to tell me that you met with a group of people for over a year, and you donât remember their names?â
âJack, look, I told you Iâm talking to you as a friend, and I am. These people were Communistsâand none of them except the one I remember are important people today. They were just names, and they faded away. Of course, there were others in the theatre group who are people of some