bad!â
âMike, youâre acting like an ass.â Susan rolls her eyes, but itâsall for show; she knows it, Mike knows it, and my parents and I know it. Mr. Mitchell has always been this wayâloud, inappropriate, goofyâand Susan has always pretended to be
this close
to fed up with him.
âIs Remy home?â I ask, trying to change the subject.
âRemy?â Mike shakes his head. âWho the hell knows what heâs doing? Probably knocking off a 7-Eleven right about now.â
âHeâs out with friends,â Susan says, âbut heâll be home soon. Heâs excited to see you, Sam.â
Iâm sure he canât wait.
From her place beneath the kitchen table, my little sister, Hannah, taps my leg. I kneel down to meet her at eye level. âWhat are you doing down here?â
âHiding.â Hannah is five. Sheâs charming and beautiful, my motherâs new everything. Next January, Hannah will compete in her first beauty pageant. We may not have money to pay our rent every month, but somehow my mother finds room in our budget for as many dance lessons and sequined costumes as Hannahâs pursuits require.
My parents call her their miracle baby. Thatâs one way of putting it, I guess. Theyâve always used little euphemisms to explain the wide age gaps between some of their children: Gretchen was their âoopsâ baby; I was their âpleasant surprise.â Out of their four children, only Turtle was planned. Hannah wasnât an accident, but I wouldnât call her âplannedâ as much as Iâd call her ⦠I donât know. Something else.
âCome on up. Everybody is nice, I promise.â
She pops a thumb into her mouth and shakes her head. Sheâsnot supposed to be sucking her thumb. Mom has tried to break her of the habit by wiping her nail with acetone to make it taste bad.
âWhy are you being shy?â
She shrugs and removes her thumb just enough to speak clearly. âI want to go home.â
âWe are home. Come on, youâll be fine.â Before I have a chance to stand up, she scoots past me and goes running down the hallway. The Mitchells barely get a glimpse of her ruffled yellow dress and black patent leather mini-heels before she disappears into the dining room. For the briefest moment, I catch a look of horror on Susan Mitchellâs face, and I know exactly what sheâs thinking. I mean, she knew my parents had another child after Turtle disappeared, but I guess seeing her in the flesh really drives home the point: Hannah is their do-over.
âIs she okay upstairs by herself?â Susanâs gaze lingers on the empty hallway as Hannahâs footsteps fade above us.
âSheâs not by herself,â I say. âGretchen is up there, too, but I think sheâs in the shower.â
My momâs smile always seems genuine, even when itâs not. Itâs a skill she picked up as a teenage beauty queen. âWhy donât you go check on her?â She beams at me. Her eyes sparkle, but her jaw is clenched.
âOkay.â I pause. âDo you mean Hannah? Or Gretchen?â
âShe means Gretchen.â Mike winks at me. âGo make sure she doesnât already have a boy up there in her bedroom.â He winces as the words are still leaving his mouth. âChrist, thatâs not what I meant. Iâm sorry.â
My mom pretends he didnât say anything that would require an apology. âYouâve been getting some sun, Mike. You look great.â
My dad hands him a fresh beer. âHave something to wash your foot down.â Beads of sweat are gathered along his hairline, even though the house is cool. A fat vein pulses on the side of his neck. âDrink up, buddy. Itâs five oâclock somewhere, right?â
Gretchen is on the floor in our parentsâ bedroom. Her hair is wrapped in a towel, and sheâs wearing a