grew on their barren surfaces.
It was time for Whiskerâs decision: left or right?
He held the key in front of him and, imagining the island was the map, aligned the shaft with the centre of the mountains. Light sparkled through tiny rust holes in the surface of the key and filled the round hole at its base.
Whisker looked beyond the cliffs, beyond the rocks, beyond the lagoon to the only glimmer of beauty on the entire island: the Rock of Hope. He could just make out the shape â a white rock, bathed in sunlight and surrounded by flowing water.
He lowered the key but kept his gaze. His line of sight led directly through a narrow passage between the rocks.
âKeep Hope in your sights,â Whisker thought aloud. And then it came to him. âOf course. The riddle is meant to be taken literally. Thereâs only one way to keep Hope in our sights and thatâs â¦â
âRight or left?â the Captain bellowed. âI need an answer.â
âNeither!â Whisker shouted. âSail straight ahead.â
âWHAT?â Pete cried from the deck. âWeâll be wrecked on the rocks!â
âBeaten to breadcrumbs!â Mr Tribble gasped.
âPounded into pancakes!â Emmie squeaked.
Fred licked his lips. âMmm, pancakes â¦â
Pete kicked Fred with his pencil. âYouâre not helping. None of you are helping.â He pointed a bony finger up at Whisker. âGive me one logical reason why we should listen to you? And it better not involve that blasted riddle. Itâs led to nothing but trouble.â
Whisker dropped his chin and stared at his toes.
âI donât know,â he mumbled. âMaybe the water is too shallow for the creature ⦠or maybe itâs too narrow between the rocks ⦠or maybe the wind is calmer â¦â
âThree great reasons,â Horace chimed in. âIâm convinced. Off we go then.â
Pete stamped his pencil leg in defiance. âCall a vote, Captain.â
The Captain studied the faces of his crew and nodded. âAs you know, only full members of the crew are permitted to vote. All those in favour of sailing straight through the rocks raise your paws now.â
Horace and Fred raised their paws. Smudge stuck four arms into the air and blew off the barrel. Ruby gave Whisker one of her expressionless stares and raised her paw.
âFour votes seals it,â the Captain confirmed.
Pete snorted in disgust and clomped into the navigation room. Whisker mouthed an awkward thanks to Ruby, and turned to the Captain. The Captain hadnât shifted his paws from the wheel, not even to vote, and the Apple Pie was already heading straight into the rocks.
âYou said straight,â he said in a low voice. âI sailed straight. The vote was merely a formality.â
âDo you honestly think we can make it through?â Whisker asked.
âItâs a tight squeeze,â the Captain said, âbut you were right about the wind. Itâs much calmer in here.â
Whisker wondered if the Captain was simply being polite. The wind swirled in mighty gusts around him, whipping up the waves and sending them crashing over the rocks. The Apple Pie rocked up and down in the centre of the narrow passage like a rubber duck in a bath tub.
âA little to your starboard, Captain,â Ruby called out. âI can see the bottom and thereâs a rock ledge coming up.â
The Captain gave the wheel a gentle spin and the ship turned to its right.
âPull in the sails,â he ordered. âToo much speed and weâll collide with a rock.â
The twins tinkered with their mice knots, adjusting the sails, and the Apple Pie slowed its pace. Whisker held up the key. The Rock of Hope was still in view.
The crew remained alert and on edge as the Apple Pie manoeuvred through the rocks. Fred and Smudge stood lookout on either side of the ship, surveying the ocean; Horace waited