until just the other day I happened to notice the mixed-up nature of a group of people sitting around one table. They were talking back and forth, the way people do in here that never even saw each other before, and passing the ketchup, and Iâll tell you who they were. Sitting on one side was an insurance broker from Maiden Lane, and next to him was a fishmonger named Mr. Frank Wilkisson whoâs a member of a family thatâs had a stand in the Old Market three generations, and next to him was a young Southerner that youâre doing good if you understand half what he says who drives one of those tremendous big refrigerator trucks that they call reefers and hits the market every four or five days with a load of shrimp from little shrimp ports in Florida and Georgia. Sitting on the other side was a lady who holds a responsible position in Continental Casualty up on William Street and comes in here for bouillabaisse, only we call it
ciuppin di pesce
and cook it the way itâs cooked fishing-family style back in Recco, and next to her was an old gentleman who works in J. P. Morgan & Companyâs banking house and youâd think heâd order something expensive like pompano but he always orders cod cheeks and if weâre out of that he orders cod roe and if weâre out of that he orders broiled cod and God knows weâre never out of that, and next to him was one of the bosses in Mooneyâs coffee-roasting plant at Fulton and Front. And sitting at the aisle end of the table was a man known all over as Cowhide Charlie who goes to slaughterhouses and buys green cowhides and sells them to fishing-boat captains to rig to the undersides of their drag nets to keep them from getting bottom-chafed and rock-cut and heâs always bragging that right this very minute his hides are rubbing the bottom of every fishing bank from Nantucket Shoals to the Virginia Capes.â
Louie said that some days, particularly Fridays, the place is jammed around one oâclock and latecomers crowd together just inside the door and stand and wait and stare, and he said that this gets on his nerves. He said he had come to the conclusion that he would have to go ahead and put in some tables on the second floor.
âI wouldâve done it long ago,â he said, âexcept I need the second floor for other things. This building doesnât have a cellar. South Street is old filled-in river swamp, and the cellars along here, what few there are, the East River leaks into them every high tide. The second floor is my cellar. I store supplies up there, and I keep my Deepfreeze up there, and the waiters change their clothes up there. I donât know what Iâll do without it, only I got to make room someway.â
âThat ought to be easy,â I said. âYouâve got four empty floors up above.â
âYou mean those boarded-up floors,â Louie said. He hesitated a moment. âDidnât I ever tell you about the upstairs in here?â he asked. âDidnât I ever tell you about those boarded-up floors?â
âNo,â I said.
âThey arenât empty,â he said
âWhatâs in them?â I asked.
âI donât know,â he said. âIâve heard this and Iâve heard that, but I donât know. I wish to God I did know. Iâve wondered about it enough. Iâve rented this building twenty-two years, and Iâve never been above the second floor. The reason being, thatâs as far as the stairs go. After that, you have to get in a queer old elevator and pull yourself up. Itâs an old-fashioned hand-power elevator, what they used to call a rope-pull. I wouldnât be surprised itâs the last of its kind in the city. I donât understand the machinery of it, the balancing weights and the cables and all that, but the way itâs operated, thereâs a big iron wheel at the top of the shaft and the wheelâs got a groove in