by instinct and preconception as by steady analysis of the reports placed on their desks. Lloyd George in particular went his own way in his pursuit of Britain’s post-war economic recovery, stealing a march on France and America by authorizing the 1921 trade agreement with Soviet Russia. He had an exaggerated belief in the erosion of communism that would result in Russia. As a result he donated a breathing space to Lenin for his New Economic Policy, decisively enabling the Soviet state to restore its economy and stabilize its control over society.
This book takes up an international vantage point on Soviet Russia and the West. The foreigners who reported, denounced, eulogized, negotiated, spied on, subverted or attacked Russia in 1917–21 rest in their graves. The Russians – Reds and Whites – who fought over Russia’s future in their Civil War are long gone. Lenin’s mausoleum still stands on Red Square in Moscow, a monument to an October Revolution that shook the world’s politics to its foundations. His corpse remains there because Russian public opinion is not ready for its removal. What happened in Petrograd in late 1917 transfigured global politics in the inter-war period. Out of the maelstrom of revolutionary Russia came a powerful state – the USSR – which defeated Nazi Germany in the Second World War and for decades after 1945 was locked in the contest of the Cold War against the US and its allies. The October Revolution gave rise to questions which remain important today, questions that find expression in the polarities of democracy and dictatorship, justice and terror, social fairness and class struggle, ideological absolutism and cultural pluralism, national sovereignty and armed international intervention. This is a cardinal reason why the history of Soviet Russia and the West continues to command attention.
PART ONE
REVOLUTION
PART TWO
SURVIVAL
PART THREE
PROBINGS
PART FOUR
STALEMATE
SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY
Archives
Arkhiv Prezidenta Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Moscow [APRF]
Bodleian Library, Oxford
Papers of Alfred Milner, Viscount Milner, 1824–1955
Gosudarstvenny Arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Moscow [GARF]
Hoover Institution Archives, Stanford University, Stanford, CA [HIA]
American Relief Administration Russian Unit
Vladimir N. Bashkirov Papers
Communist International Instructions
Merian C. Cooper Papers
Theodore Draper Papers
Paul Dukes Papers
Arthur M. Free Papers
T. T. C. Gregory Papers
George Halonen Papers
George A. Hill Papers
Ronald Hilton Papers
Herbert Hoover Collection
Hungarian Subject Collection
N. A. Ioffe Papers
Henry James Papers
William J. Kelley Papers
Nicolai Koestner Papers
Aleksandr Vasil’evich Kolchak Papers
General A. A. von Lampe Papers
Robert Lansing Papers
M. J. Larsons Papers
Ivy Litvinov Papers
Robert Hamilton Bruce Lockhart Papers
Jay Lovestone Papers
Gibbes Lykes Papers
L. K. Martens Papers
Frank E. Mason Papers
Russia. Posol’stvo
Russian Subject Collection
Jacques Sadoul Papers
Boris Savinkov Papers
US Consulate – Leningrad [ sic ]
US Department of State: Records of the Department of State Relating to Political Relations between Russia (and the Soviet Union) and Other States, 1910–29
Pëtr Vasil’evich Vologodskii Papers
P. N. Vrangel Papers
Nikolai Yudenich Papers
National Archives, Kew
HO = Home Office
FO = Foreign Office
KV = Security Service
Rossiiskii Gosudarstvennyi Arkhiv Sotsial’no-Politicheskoi Istorii, Moscow [RSGASPI]
fond 2
fond 17
fond 46
fond 325
fond 5
fond 44
fond 89
fond 515
Rossiiskii Gosudarstvennyi Voennyi Arkhiv, Moscow [RGVA]
Russian and Eurasian Studies Centre, St Antony’s College, Oxford [RESC]
Ivy Litvinov Papers
Churchill Archives Centre, Churchill College, Cambridge
Churchill Papers
Contemporary Periodicals
Byulleten’ Narodnogo Komissariata Inostrannykh Del
Daily Express
Izvestiya Tsentral’nogo Komiteta KPSS
Daily Herald
Labour Leader
Daily