might have been a coincidence, but McConnell didnât much believe in coincidences.
A chilling thought entered her mind. There had been another witness in this case, a female college student from the University of Utah. When records came back confirming Ginsbergâs status as a witness in the case, Kate also asked for the name of the second witness and her home address.
A patrol sergeant, Dennis Martinez, met Kate at Robin Joinerâs home. It was an older apartment complex about a mile south and west of the university campus. Joiner occupied a ground floor unit that had a covered patio and a sliding door at the rear. Kate sent Martinez behind the apartment to cover the patio exit while she approached the front door. She saw it immediately. The door had fresh pry marks dug into the wood around the lock. Somebody had used a screwdriver or pry bar to jimmy the lock. Kate drew her nine millimeter, quietly turned the door knob, and pushed open the front door. She paused momentarily. The apartment was dark and quiet.
âHello, Salt Lake City Police.â
Silence.
She slipped into the apartment and turned on the light in the hallway. She moved quickly through the living room, opened the drapes, and unlocked the sliding patio door. A cursory search of the apartment failed to turn up any sign of Robin Joiner. Equally disturbing, it was clear that the apartment had been tossed. Drawers in the kitchen, bathroom, and bedroom had been pulled open, and the contents dumped on the floor. Somebody was obviously looking for something.
âWhat do you make of this, Lieutenant?â
Martinez was standing in the small kitchen looking into a round fruit bowl on the dining room table containing two overly ripe bananas in it. On top of the bananas was a hand-printed note. It read: IâM LOOKING FOR YOU AND I WILL FIND YOU .
âI havenât a clue, Sergeant, but letâs not touch it. Iâd like you to sit tight for a few minutes. Iâm going to request a forensics team and see if I can locate an on-site apartment manager. Maybe the manager will be able to tell us something about the whereabouts of Ms. Joiner.â
âOkay.â
Outside McConnell found an âapartment managerâ sign stuck in the front lawn with an arrow pointing south to an adjacent building. She located a woman who was just putting the finishing touches on a lease agreement with a new tenant. When she finished, Kate introduced herself and flashed credentials.
âSorry to bother you, but Iâm looking for the tenant in apartment number 106. Robin Joiner is her name.â
âI havenât seen Robin for the past couple of days but thatâs not unusual. Is everything okay?â
âI hope so, but weâre not sure. Does Robin rent the unit by herself or does she have a roommate?â
âThe lease is in Robinâs name only, no roommate as far as I know.â
âHow about friends? Do you have any idea who she hangs out with?â
âThatâs almost impossible to keep track of. Most of our tenants are students attending Westminster College or the University of Utah. Weâve got people coming and going at all hours of the day and night all the time.â
âDo you recall ever seeing her with anyone?â
She paused. âCome to think of it, I guess I have seen Robin a time or two, mostly with young women I assumed were her friends, probably students. But I donât have any names for you. Sorry. Can I ask what this is about?â
âRobin is a witness in a case of ours. I just need to ask her a few questions. How about boyfriends? Anybody come to mind?â
Another pause. âYeah, one guy a few times. Never met him though. Iâm sorry that Iâm not being more helpful.â
âThatâs okay. Youâre doing the best you can. Do you think you could describe the boyfriend for me?â
âSure. He was a cute guy, tall, maybe six-two, six-three, slim