weâd just been there on honeymoon.
Often, I wonder about other peopleâs lives. What kind of job does that beautiful woman do? A model perhaps? But today I canât stop my thoughts from turning back to myself. To my own life. What would my life be like if Iâd become that social worker instead of a lawyer? What if, just after moving to London, I hadnât gone to that party with my new flatmate, something Iâd normally always say no to? What if I hadnât spilled my wine on the beige carpet? What if the kindly sandy-haired man (âHi, Iâm Edâ) with the navy cravat and well-educated voice hadnât helped me to mop it up, telling me that in his view the carpet was very dull anyway and needed âlivening upâ. What if I hadnât been so drunk (out of nerves) that I told him about my brotherâs death when heâd asked about my own family? What if this funny man who made me laugh, but listened at the same time, hadnât proposed on the second date? What if his arty, privileged world (so clearly different from mine) hadnât represented an escape from all the horrors of my past â¦
Are you telling me the truth about your brother?
My motherâs voice cuts through the swathes of commuter crows and pulls me on an invisible towline away from London to Devon, where we moved two years after Daniel had arrived.
I wrap my grown-up coat around me and throw her voice out of the window, on to the tracks. I donât have to listen to it now. Iâm an adult. Married. I have a proper job with responsibilities. Responsibilities I should be paying attention to now, rather than going back in time. âYou
need to picture what the prosecution is thinking,â the senior partner is always saying. âGet one stage ahead.â
Shuffling in an attempt to make room between two sets of sturdy, grey-trousered knees â one on either side of my seat â I open my bulging black briefcase. No easy task in a crammed carriage. Shielding the case summary with my hand (weâre not meant to read private documents in public), I scan it to refresh my memory.
CONFIDENTIAL
Pro Bono case
Joe Thomas, 30, insurance salesman. Convicted in 1998 of murdering Sarah Evans, 26, fashion sales assistant and girlfriend of the accused, by pushing her into a scalding-hot bath. Heart failure combined with severe burns the cause of death. Neighbours testified to sounds of a violent argument. Bruises on the body consistent with being forcibly pushed.
Itâs the water bit that freaks me out. Murder should be committed with something nasty like a sharp blade or a rock, or poison, like the Borgias. But a bath should be safe. Comforting. Like the woody-green District line. Like honeymoons.
The train jolts erratically and Iâm thrown against the knees on my left and then those on my right. My papers scatter on the wet floor. Horrified, I gather them up, but itâs too late. The owner of the trousers on my right is
handing back the case summary, but not before his eyes have taken in the neat typed writing.
My first murder trial
, I want to say, if only to smooth the wary look in his eyes.
But instead I blush furiously and stuff the papers back into my bag, aware that if my boss was present I would be sacked on the spot.
All too soon, the train stops. Itâs time to get out. Time to try and save a man whom I already loathe â a bath! â when all I want is to be back in Italy. To live our honeymoon again.
To get it right this time.
Whenever Iâve thought about a prison, Iâve always imagined something like Colditz. Not a long drive that reminds me of Edâs parentsâ rambling pile in Gloucestershire. Iâve only been there once, but that was enough. The atmosphere was freezing, and Iâm not just talking about the absence of central heating.
âAre you sure this is right?â I ask the taxi driver.
He nods, and I can feel his grin even though