forty acres. A lot of rocks around the shore. Just one house on it, I thinkâright?â
âExactly. Actually, thereâs the main houseâand I think thereâs a little cabin at the other end of the island, and maybe another little outbuilding.â
âSo, the case is about the island?â Fiona asked.
Georgia nodded her head but then paused.
âWell, about Stony Island, yes. But itâs much more than that.â
âWhat do you mean?â Will asked.
âFirst of all, I canât see into the manâs heart, of course. But for as long as Iâve known Jonathan Joppa, thereâs been a real sadness there. His wife died back when he was the assistant pastor at that large church in Charlotteâ¦oh, what was the nameâ¦oh, yes. First Evangelical Church of Charlotte. She had had health problems. Then, shortly after that, he left and accepted the pastorate of that small church in Manteoâ¦Safe Harbor Community Church. Here in the Outer Banks. He never remarried.â
âSo, how is the island involved?â Fiona asked.
âWell, part of this is what Jonathan Joppa told meâand the rest is what I read in the newspaper some time ago in some articles when it talked about the case. In fact, I think Bull, before his stroke, had also shared something with me. You know, Hatteras Island is a small place. News travels fast.â
âWhat news?â Will asked.
âWellâI told you that the island has remained in the Joppa family forâohâjust shy of three hundred years. And Randolph Willowby, one of the descendants of the man who originally owned the island, way back when in the 1700sârecently died. And there was a provision in his will that said Jonathan Joppa could take the island if he could clear the tarnished reputation of a distant Joppa relative.â
âWhat do you mean by tarnished? â Fiona asked, riveted on the conversation and leaning her face into both hands.
âThree hundred years ago, a distant ancestor of Jonathan Joppaâs was charged with a criminal offenseââ
âWhat kind?â Will broke in.
âPiracy,â Georgia replied.
âPiracy! â Fiona blurted out. âAre you serious?â
âAbsolutely, but all of that was a long time agoâyou know all the stories about the pirate Blackbeard, Willie, right?â
Will nodded and chuckled, thinking back to the tour guide.
âSo, as I understand it,â Georgia continued, âif this Pastor Joppa is able to disprove the criminal charges brought against this distant relative of hisâthen the island goes to him. Iâm afraid thatâs as much as I know.â
The three were quiet for a moment, as they listened to the surf roll and crash down below the house. The candles were flickering low. Will offered to do the dishes and, as he rose from the table, he asked one other question.
âIt sounds like an unusual condition to put in a willâto clear the reputation of the family name. But I have a bigger question. Doesnât this guy already have a lawyer?â
âHe did,â Georgia said. âBoggs Beckford. But he was injured in a car accident. Almost died. So Reverend Joppa is looking for a new lawyer. Iâve recommended you.â
âHow valuable is the island?â Will asked nonchalantly as he was collecting the plates from the table.
âWell, I heard at the beauty shop that there is a real estate development company thatâs appraised it at two million dollars. They would like to develop some condominiums on it and would buy the island from Reverend Joppa if he wins.â
âHow long ago was all this?â Will called out from the kitchen.
âHow long ago was what?â Georgia responded.
âThis piracy charge.â
âWellâyou know your pirate historyâit would have been the early 1700s, I think, right?â
âWhen youâre talking about charges