Millersâ property and five of their neighborsâ.
âThe killer used one of these animal trails to get in and out of the creek. Had to. We didnât find his prints leaving the creek because they were trod over at some point after he left her body at the Millersâ, covered up by hoofprints.â
I looked at Grady. He was frowning, but he didnât say anything.
âWe saw dairy cows out in a couple of these fields yesterday.â I tapped two Post-it notes Iâd put up with cow stick figures. My attempt at high art. âSo for sure he could have used either of these trails. As for the others, all these farms have at least a horse or two for the buggies. Weâll have to interview the farmers to know if their animals were out between midnight and when we were looking, Iâd say as late as ten A.M. yesterday.â
âHe could have kept to the creek. Couldâve walked miles,â Grady countered.
âEven in the water, it wouldnât have been easy to manage adead body, and it was damned freezing. Plus, we looked up and down both banks of the creek and didnât find fresh prints coming out of it for at least a mile. And there arenât any more animal tracks along it for a good ways either.â I tapped the paper. âHe used one of these trails, Grady. Which means he
knows
this place. He knew where those trails were and when the animals moved. He came from one of these farms.â
It was the first time Iâd said it out loud, but Iâd started thinking it yesterday afternoon. I knew Grady didnât want to hear it. Then again, I didnât want a lot of the shit that had happened to me. Life sucked that way.
Grady rubbed at his jaw. He looked around as if worried about being overheard. But most of the detectives didnât get in until after seven. He still lowered his voice.
âOkay, I agree that he knows the area. That doesnât mean heâs Amish. He could be someone who works with the Amishâa driver, someone who picks up dairy or produce. Hell, a mailman. Or a customer.â
He grabbed my Post-it pad and began scribbling. He tore off the top page and slapped it over one of the properties marked
Fisher
. âEggs and dairy,â he said, repeating what heâd written on the note. He scribbled another one and put it on the map. âChicken coops.â Another. âBaked goods.â Another. âMules.â He waved his hand. âAll these farmers sell goods directly off their farms, which means they have customers driving in and out all the time. Any of those customers could have thought,
Gee whiz, where should I dump this body? How âbout where I buy my eggs? No one would ever guess because Iâm such a clever bastard.
â
âJust because you stop in someoneâs driveway to buy eggsdoesnât mean you can see the creek or the animal trails leading to it. The creekâs in a gully.â
âMaybe they wandered around a bit one fine spring day. Maybe their dog took off across a field and they chased it. Maybe they chatted with the farmer and he mentioned it. Could have been months ago, even years, and only now they had a reason to use that information. Hell, it could have been a fisherman or hunter who wandered up and down that creek in his youth. These farms have had cows and horses living there for a hundred years, which means those trails have been there forever.â
He had a point. Maybe I was getting ahead of myself. âRight. We should get started on customer lists, and lists of anyone who visits these farms regularly. But . . . Iâm gonna say this, Grady, at least once.â
I waited until he looked at me.
âIâm not ruling out anything, not yet. These farmers and their families have to be considered suspects, at least until we can cross them off officially.â
I made it sound logical, but it was more than that to me. It was a gut feeling, a feeling that said
Tim Lahaye, Jerry B. Jenkins