The prior pastor had led the church through a capital campaign that had raised enough money for an impressive down payment on its new worship facility. The rest of the project had been funded through a low-interest loan it intended to renegotiate later. âLaterâ landed on Alexâs watch. Unfortunately, thanks to the post-census meltdown of â42, banks were now charging exorbitant interest rates. The higher mortgage payment coupled with lower giving translated into increasingly tense meetings with the church finance committee that, it just so happened, was also chaired by Phil Crawford.
Outreach : Six months after Alex arrived the board realized a younger face with an engaging teaching style was not enough to restore the churchâs glory days. So they formed something they called the Dream Team: a committee that would solicit suggestions about how the church might more effectively reach the surrounding community. Every board meeting featured a new list of ideas gleaned from a variety of sources, including what Phil called âbenchmarkingâ trips to larger, more successful area churches. Only a few of the suggestions ever got implemented, and none of those received the promised budget or volunteer support. But that didnât stop the flood of dreams from consuming an inordinate share of the pastorâs schedule.
The fifth item carried the label Bentley Donation . It had triggered thirty minutes of disagreement just before Alex left the room.
âThe circle on the right,â Phil began while pointing to his diagram, âis the younger demographic of the church. They represent relevance and impact. To the degree this circle expandsââa wave of his hand caused the circle to growââwe know we are accomplishing our core mission.â
To his own surprise, Alex followed the point. He even felt himself nodding in agreement.
âThe circle on the left represents our older members.â Phil waved his hand across the shape, prompting it to shrink. A second wave shrank it further. âThey represent our economic engine.â
âOur what?â asked Brandon, the youngest member of the board.
âOur economic engine,â Phil repeated, as if saying it louder would provide sufficient explanation.
Brandonâs question gave Mary Sanchez confidence to speak. âI donât know what that means.â
âThat makes three of us,â confessed Roberto Wilson.
âFour,â Alex added, raising his hand.
Phil rolled his eyes toward Kenny James, who gladly accepted the hand-off.
âEvery business and nonprofit entity must ask itself several strategic questions, including âWhat drives our economic engine?â Or, in laymanâs terms,â he said with a wink toward the pastor, ââHow do we make money?ââ
âBut we donât make money. We receive donations,â Alex reminded him.
âSemantics,â Phil interjected. âWe arenât that different from any other business. We provide a service, and people reward us by funding our product.â
âOur product?â asked Brandon.
Phil edited himself. âOur ministry, then. The point is people pay the bills by transferring money from their pockets to ours. Whatever motivates or facilitates that transfer is, in short, our economic engine.â
âI see,â Alex said guardedly.
âAn engine we need to do a better job of fueling.â
âBecause?â asked Alex.
âBecause, Pastor , we canât turn on the lights or extend impact without cold, hard cash.â
Alex folded his hands in front of himself on the table as he leaned forward, then back. âOf course,â he said. âAnd the older donors give a higher portion of their income than younger donors.â
âExactly!â Kenny interjected as if to rescue the moment. âBut they do so because they care about reaching the younger