Sugarfootâs training.
When Ed came back from the house, he looked resigned.
âWhat is it, Dad?â Ann asked.
Ed shook his head slowly, indicating it was nothing Ann would like.
âI talked to our insurance man. He said Sugarfootâs a âproven liabilityâ and we should get rid of him.â
âNo!â Ann shouted.
âOh, Ed.â
âWhatâs that meanâa âproven liabilityâ? Usually I can figure things out, but this oneâs tricky,â Ann chattered nervously. âLiabilityâ¦but wait. He said we should get rid of Sugarfoot. That doesnât mean we have to, right?â
âIf we had a dog that bit people, and we already knew it was dangerous and kept it around, and then it hurt someoneâ¦â
âIt would be easy for someone to sue us and win,â Ramona finished for her husband.
âYep.â He nodded. âHe said it would serve us bestâif the Mookinis do sueâto be able to document in court that weâve removed all threats to ranch visitors.â
âBut why?â Ann demanded. âWe just wonât let him do it again.â
âWe thought we could keep him from doing itthis time,â Ramona said.
âYou could have them sign something like we have for guest riders,â Darby suggested, âa form that says they ride at their own risk.â
âWe could, but thereâs more,â Ed told them. âIf we knowingly keep a menace, it could invalidate all of our ranch insurance.â
Before moving to Hawaii, Darby hadnât thought about insurance. It was no more than another bill in the stack her mother tried to pay each month. But earthquakes and tsunamis had taught her that adults paid those bills for a reason. If the Potters had no insurance and another earthquake opened zigzag fissures under their house or a storm flattened their riding arena, theyâd have to use all their savings to protect Heart of Hawaii.
What if they ran out of money and moved back to Nevada, just when Darby and her mom were settling here? Darby closed her eyes and wished it was yesterday, and none of this had happened. She couldnât stand the idea of losing her best friend.
âBut wait,â Ramona said. âWhat if he was cured?â
Ed looked puzzled. âThereâs no cure for crazy.â
âEd Potter, youâve been around horses as long as I have,â Ramona pretended to scold her husband. âYou know something causes a problem like this. We just havenât figured out what it is yet.â
âWe canât give up on him, Dad,â Ann added.
âIf she did take us to courtâand really, I just donâtsee that happeningââRamona looked thoughtful as she continuedââbut if she did, what if we could demonstrate that he was over thisâ¦â She searched for a word but only came up with âThis thing.â
âWeâll bring in an expert,â Ann declared.
âWe have pretâ near a century of horse expertise standinâ right hereââEd gestured at the four of themââand Iâm not payinâ for a horse psychiatrist, Anna Susannah! Thatâs just the last straw.â Darby was just thinking sheâd never heard Annâs entire name when her best friend put her hands on her hips and faced off with her dad.
âWhy not?â Ann asked.
Darby took a deep breath as Annâs glance flashed between her father and Sugarfoot. Ann usually thought before she spoke, but Darby was afraid Ann was getting carried away.
âWhy not?â Ann repeated. âWe can afford it!â
âWell, we wonât be able to for long, if our insurance company cancels us!â Edâs voice grew louder with each word.
Darby wanted to cover her ears. She shouldnât be here in the midst of this family turmoil. Even if she had caused it.
âIt wouldnât have to be a horse psychiatrist,â