read:
Is this Evan Murphy? YES. NO. DONE TAGGING.
âWhat the hell?â I said.
Toni brought her face closer to the screen. âWhoâs Evan Murphy?â
âI donât know, but FriendShare seems to think heâs my dead boyfriend.â
She shook her head. âStupid website. Itâs probably glitchy or something. Just say ânoâ and then hit âpost.ââ
My finger hovered over the mouse, but I didnât click âno.â My muscles tightened into steel coils. It was probably nothing. It
had
to be nothing. But I needed to see.
With a trembling hand, I clicked on Evanâs name.
âWhat are you doing?â Toni asked.
âI just want to see who he is,â I said. âNow Iâm curious.â
âYouâre postponing the closure. I knew youâd chicken out. You need to do this!â
She continued to lovingly lecture me, but I couldnât hear her anymore. All I heard was the rush of blood through my head and the ragged, sharp intakes of my own breath.
Because the page had loaded. Evan Murphy lived a few towns away and looked
exactly
like Flynn. Except he was very much alive.
CHAPTER 2
D oritos hit the floor as the open bag fell from Toniâs hand. âWhoa . . .â
âYeah,â I breathed.
âWhat? Who?â
Toni continued her one-word questions as I clicked around, trying to access anything else on Evan Murphyâs page. But he had a good amount of privacy settings on, and the only thing I could see was that one small profile picture and his town name, Littlefieldâonly fifteen minutes away.
Toni jabbed a finger at the photo. âItâs Flynn. I mean, it
is
him, right?â
âIt canât be,â I said. âI donât know.â
âHow can you not know?â Toni screeched. âFriendShare matched his face to this guy. Itâs him! Look!â
I didnât know how I was staying so calm. Toni was clearly going bananas. But it was like my brain had shut off all emotion so it could focus. I clicked on the photo in an attempt to enlarge it, but the resolution was terrible when I tried to zoom in. The face was Flynnâs face. Those steely gray eyes that were so hard to ignore. The slope of his jaw. The sly, one-sided grin.
But it couldnât be him. I searched for something sane to grasp on to.
âHeâs wearing a baseball hat,â I said quickly. âFlynn never wore hats.â
âHe also never said his name was Evan Murphy and he lived in Littlefield. Being an undercover hat lover obviously wasnât his biggest secret.â
I needed to get away from the computer, from the familiar face smiling at me on the screen. I pushed the chair back and stood up. âItâs just someone who looks eerily like him.â
âNot eerily,â Toni said. âExactly.â
I pulled my hair back and held it at the nape of my neck. âCould he, like, have a twin living in another town with a different last name?â I said, thinking out loud. âI know itâs crazy, but what else could it be?â
âHe could be alive,â Toni said.
I sank down onto the edge of my bed as a wave of nausea washed over me. I put my face in my hands and rubbed circles on my forehead. Could Flynn really be alive? How would that be possible? And . . . he let me think he was dead? Would he do that?
How
could he do that?
I dropped my hands and looked up at Toni. She was staring at me with a wary expression, probably waiting for me to lose it.
âItâs impossible,â I said.
âThere was no funeral,â she countered.
That was true. Iâd never met Flynnâs parents. He never wanted to talk about them, and I assumed he never told them about me. I never got word about a wake or funeral, and it wasnât printed in the paper. Flynn had lived in town only a couple of months, and he didnât even go to our school. He went to St.