on my forehead. âAre you a teenager?â
âYou better stay back then,â I warn, my tone light and airy. âIâve got the hormones for some scary behavior.â
His laughter is a short burst, then silence expands between us. I sip my Diet Coke, which foams up like the tension building inside me. âAre you having trouble with Ivy?â
âDepends on the moment.â He grins, but thereâs tension around the edges. âSheâs normal. I think. But I donâthave a lot to compare her to. Itâs times like this when I miss Gwen.â
I donât know how to respond. I donât know how to help. I know the damage Gwen caused, the anger and betrayal. Ben rarely mentions his ex-wife anymore; but when he does, it feels like a shovel jabbing at a pile of hurt, anger, and betrayal.
âThereâs no guarantee if Gwen had stayed that she and Ivy would be close.â Case in point: my relationship with my mother. âThereâs no such thing as a perfect teenager. Or the perfect parent.â Or a perfect life. Over the past few years Iâve discovered uncertainty is the one certainty.
âThatâs true.â He leans against the kitchen counter, one shoulder tilted downward. âThing is, Iâve been meaning to talk to her about her mother. Explain some things she should know and understand. But itâs never a good time. Sheâs always angry or upset. Usually at me. And this would make it worse.â
Despair washes over me. Thereâs so much hurt in the world, in this very room. Sometimes I feel as if Iâm drowning in it. âDo you ever wonder why this has happened? Gwen ⦠and Stu? Why she abandoned your family? Why Stu had to die? I mean, whatâs the point?â
âAre you asking why God allowed it?â His brown eyes narrow on me.
I shrug, shift from one foot to the other. Maybe thatâs what Iâve been asking but secretly was afraid a lightning bolt would hit me if I dared. âMaybe I am.â
âIâll tell you, Claudia, I havenât a clue.â His answer stuns me. Then he laughs, a caustic sound. âIâve wrestled with thatquestion a lot. Sometimes I think itâs my fault about Gwen.
The consequences of sin and all that.â
âYour fault?â
âSure. Did I miss the warning signs? Looking back, there were things about Gwen that I should have noticed, should have worried about. Before and after we married. But I ignored them.â
âItâs not your fault that Gwen walked out.â
âMaybe. Maybe not. But maybe I could have spared all of us this pain if Iâd paid attention to the signs. Then again, I wouldnât have Ivy.â
âSo whatâs the reason for Stu suffering, dying so young?â
He leans back against the counter and crosses his arms over his chest. âI donât have an answer. I donât have answers for all my questions. I trust thereâs a reason.â
âTrust,â I scoff. âLike trusting Santaâs going to come down the chimney?â
âGod isnât a myth. Or some jolly elf that brings presents.â
Maybe thatâs why Iâm disappointed. Maybe I expected more. But then what or who is this God whoâs supposed to be running things?
The back door opens and bangs against the wall. Rae rushes into the kitchen, her face reddened, her fists tight.
âWhatâs wrong?â I ask, rushing forward.
âI caught someone stealing!â
Ben grabs the golf club like a baseball bat.
Rae slaps a baby rattle on the counter. âCan you believe that?â
âSomeone stole a baby rattle?â Ben asks. âWhereâdââ
âWhereâs the money box, Rae?â I ask, thinking of the Monkees lunch box Iâm using for a bank.
âI gave it to Ivy to watch.â She shifts her gaze to Ben, then back to me. âWas that okay?â
âIâm sure